I didn't let him! It was an accident. When he first offered me one, I turned him down, but I, I didn't know he'd already filled a prop beaker with them. So... yeah. My SQUIP got activated, and he synced it to his and-

[And this is when it gets really disturbing, and she just knows Santana might rip poor Jeremy a new one when she hears about it.]

...His goal was to get me to like him, so it forced me to tell him how I felt.

He was the person I was to be with every day
There wasn't anything else I could ever say
He's the guy I was so kind of into
A guy I could only be into
Was it really true...?